In a development worthy of a courtroom drama script, Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni came face-to-face today for the first time since their public fallout. The tense reunion took place inside a law office in Manhattan for Lively’s deposition as part of her case against Baldoni, following drama during the filming of It Ends With Us.

Justin Baldoni’s drastic step during Blake Lively’s deposition reportedly stunned both legal teams. According to a source, his dramatic demand to attend his “It Ends With Us” co-star’s deposition created a toxic environment.

It's worth noting that Judge Liman had issued a protective order granting Lively's legal team the right to control where the deposition took place